3 Follow-Up Mistakes That Are Costing You Sales (And How to Fix Them)

If you're buying mortgage protection leads but struggling to close deals, you're not alone. Many agents face the same frustration — getting leads, reaching out once or twice, and hearing crickets. The issue isn't always the quality of the leads. Often, it's how they're being worked.

In this post, we’ll break down the simple (but costly) follow-up mistakes most agents make — and show you how small changes can lead to big wins. Whether you're new to the game or a seasoned pro, these reminders can help you close more this week.

You’re Getting Leads. So Why Aren’t You Closing?

If you’re an insurance agent buying leads every week, but not seeing results, you’re not alone.

The truth is, most agents don’t close because they don’t follow up the right way.

At Aria Leads, we generate Mortgage Protection leads every day for agents like you, but it’s not just about getting the lead. It’s what you do next that counts.

Let’s break down the 3 most common follow-up mistakes we see agents make, and how you can avoid them to start closing more policies this week.

Mistake #1 – Waiting Too Long to Call

People Don’t Respond to Scripts

If your first message sounds like it was copy-pasted from a corporate handbook, you’re losing trust fast.

Your leads want to feel like they’re talking to a real person, someone they can trust with something as serious as protecting their mortgage and family.

The Fix

Start with a friendly text message that includes:

• Your full name

• A clear mention of why you’re reaching out

• A friendly photo (if possible)

• A call to action like “Is this a good time to connect?”

Human connection wins. Every time.

Mistake #3 – Giving Up Too Soon

Most Sales Don’t Happen on Day 1

If your first message sounds like it was copy-pasted from a corporate handbook, you’re losing trust fast.

Most prospects need 2–3 follow-ups before they convert. Not because they’re not interested, but because they’re busy.

The Fix

Set a system to follow up:

✅ Day 1: Call + text

✅ Day 2: Second call

✅ Day 3: Friendly check-in with value-based messaging

Be persistent, but always respectful. You’re showing them that you care — and that you’re not going away.

The Leads Work — If You Work Them

Aria Leads provides agents with real, high-intent leads, but follow-up is your secret weapon.

Here’s how each lead type can fit your follow-up strategy:

✅ Premium Mailers

• Leads from homeowners who called in after receiving a Mortgage Protection letter.

• They’ve shown interest, you just need to guide the conversation.

✅ Digital Leads

• Verified with OTP (One-Time Password), ensuring real contact info.

• Prospects filled out forms online looking for Mortgage Protection.

• Delivered directly to your CRM, fast and ready.

✅ Marketplace Leads

• High-quality, budget-friendly leads you can buy anytime.

• Great for volume follow-up, script testing, or dialing practice.

Final Thought: Leads Don’t Close Themselves — Agents Do

You don’t need better leads. You need a better follow-up system.

Commit to these 3 changes this week:

1. Call leads in 15 minutes or less

2. Text with warmth and intention

3. Follow up for at least 3 days

And watch your close rate rise.

Conclusion

Every lead is a chance to protect a family, but only if you follow up with purpose.

It’s not about being pushy. It’s about being present. The agents who close consistently aren’t lucky, they’re strategic.

They respond quickly. They connect authentically. And they don’t give up after one call.

You’ve got the tools. You’ve got the leads. Now it’s your move.

Ready to Apply These Tips?

We’ve got leads for every strategy and every budget:

➡️ Explore All Lead Types